New York’s Whistleblower Law Reaches Further Than Most Employers Assume

pexels-silverkblack-36733329

Written By: BOSS Editorial

Published: October 7, 2026

Reading Time: 7 minutes

Share this story

By Jason Tenenbaum

Ask a manager in New York what a whistleblower is and the answer usually involves an accountant, a federal agency and a fraud large enough to make the news. That picture was roughly accurate for decades. It has not been accurate since 2022, when the Legislature rewrote Labor Law Section 740, New York’s whistleblower statute. 

The current law protects ordinary complaints made inside the company, by people many employers do not think of as employees, about violations of almost any law. Employers who still work from the old picture are the ones who end up defending these cases.

Who the statute protects

Labor Law Section 740(1)(a) defines an employee as anyone who performs services for wages under the employer’s control, and then adds two groups that surprise most business owners: former employees, and natural persons working as independent contractors in furtherance of the employer’s business who are not themselves employers. The statute applies to any employer with one or more employees (Labor Law Section 740(1)(b)). A sole proprietor with a single assistant and a stable of freelance contractors is covered.

What counts as protected activity

Under Labor Law Section 740(2), an employer may not retaliate against an employee who does any of three things:

  1. Discloses, or threatens to disclose, to a supervisor or to a public body an activity, policy or practice of the employer that the employee reasonably believes violates a law, rule or regulation, or reasonably believes poses a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety;
  2. Provides information to, or testifies before, a public body investigating that activity, policy or practice; or
  3. Objects to, or refuses to participate in, that activity, policy or practice.

Three details in that text do most of the work:

  • First, the standard is reasonable belief. The employee does not have to be right that the law was broken; the question is whether the belief was reasonable.
  • Second, “law, rule or regulation” is defined broadly. Labor Law Section 740(1)(c) includes federal, state and local statutes, ordinances and executive orders, the rules and regulations issued under them, and any judicial or administrative decision, ruling or order. A complaint that a wage practice violates the Labor Law, that a workplace condition violates a safety code, or that a billing practice violates an agency rule all fit.
  • Third, the protection applies “whether or not within the scope of the employee’s job duties.” A compliance officer, bookkeeper or HR manager who raises a problem as part of the job is protected in the same way as anyone else.

The statute also protects the employee who refuses. An employee told to backdate a record, alter a report or skip a required inspection who says no is engaged in protected activity under Labor Law Section 740(2)(c).

Internal reporting comes first, with exceptions

Labor Law Section 740(3) keeps one requirement from the older law. Before an employee’s disclosure to a public body is protected, the employee must make a good faith effort to bring the problem to a supervisor and give the employer a reasonable opportunity to correct it. 

That requirement does not apply where there is an imminent and serious danger to public health or safety; where the employee reasonably believes reporting to the supervisor would lead to destruction of evidence or concealment; where the practice could reasonably be expected to endanger a minor; where the employee reasonably believes reporting would result in physical harm to anyone; or where the employee reasonably believes the supervisor already knows and will not correct it.

Two consequences follow for employers. A complaint to a supervisor is itself protected; the employee does not need to go outside the company to be covered. And “supervisor” is defined in Labor Law Section 740(1)(f) to include anyone with authority to direct the employee’s work or to take corrective action on the problem. A complaint to a shift lead or a department head counts.

What the statute treats as retaliation

Labor Law Section 740(1)(e) defines retaliatory action to include discharge, suspension, demotion, threats of any of those, and actions or threats that would adversely affect a former employee’s current or future employment. That last clause reaches references: a negative reference given because a former employee reported a problem is retaliation under the statute. The definition also expressly includes threatening to contact, or contacting, immigration authorities about the suspected status of an employee or a member of the employee’s family or household.

What a claim can cost

An employee has two years from the retaliatory action to sue (Labor Law Section 740(4)(a)), in the county where it occurred, where the employee lives, or where the employer has its principal place of business (Labor Law Section 740(4)(b)). Either side is entitled to a jury trial.

Under Labor Law Section 740(5), the court may order an injunction; reinstatement to the same or an equivalent position, or front pay instead; restoration of fringe benefits and seniority; lost wages, benefits and other remuneration; the employee’s reasonable costs, disbursements and attorney’s fees; a civil penalty of up to $10,000; and punitive damages if the violation was willful, malicious or wanton.

Section 740 is also not the only statute in play. Labor Law Section 740(7) provides that nothing in the section diminishes an employee’s rights under any other law, regulation, collective bargaining agreement or employment contract, so a whistleblower claim can be brought alongside other claims. 

A complaint about a Labor Law violation, such as unpaid wages or overtime, is separately protected by Labor Law Section 215, which prohibits retaliation against an employee who complains, reasonably and in good faith, that the employer violated the Labor Law. Section 215 authorizes a civil action within two years, reinstatement or front pay, lost compensation, attorney’s fees, and liquidated damages of up to $20,000, which Labor Law Section 215(2)(a) directs the court to award to every employee aggrieved under the section.

Public employers should note that the whistleblower protection most often invoked for public employees is Civil Service Law Section 75-b, a separate statute with its own procedures.

The defense the statute provides

Labor Law Section 740(4)(c) makes it a defense that the action taken against the employee was based on grounds other than the protected activity. In practice, that defense is only as strong as the record behind it. And Labor Law Section 740(6) allows a court, in its discretion, to award the employer attorney’s fees and costs if a claim was without basis in law or in fact.

What employers should do now

Post the notice. Labor Law Section 740(8) requires every employer to inform employees of their rights under the section by posting a notice conspicuously, in easily accessible and well-lit places employees and applicants frequent. The New York State Department of Labor publishes a notice for this purpose. Employers with remote staff should consider distributing it electronically as well.

Train the people who receive complaints: Most protected disclosures are not labeled as such. They arrive as an aside in a meeting, an email about a practice that seems wrong, or a refusal to do something. Supervisors should know that these are protected, that they must be escalated, and that the person who raised them should not be treated differently afterward.

Document legitimate decisions when they are made: The defense in Labor Law Section 740(4)(c) depends on evidence that a disciplinary or termination decision rested on other grounds. Performance problems documented before the complaint carry weight. Problems first written down after it rarely do.

Separate the decision from the complaint: Where possible, a manager who was the subject of a complaint should not be the only person deciding the complaining employee’s discipline or termination.

Treat former employees and contractors as covered: Reference practices, rehire decisions and contractor renewals are all within the statute’s reach. A neutral reference policy, applied consistently, removes one common source of claims.

Never raise immigration status in a dispute: The statute names threats to report immigration status as retaliation. That should be a hard rule for every manager.

Investigate the underlying complaint: The internal-reporting requirement in Labor Law Section 740(3) exists to give the employer a chance to fix the problem. An employer that investigates and corrects the practice is in a far better position than one that focuses on the employee who raised it.

The 2022 amendments did not create a new category of employer liability so much as bring the statute in line with how problems are actually reported in a workplace: internally, informally, and often by the people closest to the work. Employers that build their policies around that reality are the ones least likely to see Section 740 in a complaint.

Jason Tenenbaum is the founder of the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C., in Huntington Station, New York, where he represents employees in retaliation, discrimination and wage cases and injured New Yorkers in personal injury matters. This article is for general information and is not legal advice.

Photo by Vitaly Gariev